Hardside vs. Softside Luggage: How to Choose Best for You

We may receive compensation from the providers of the services and products featured on this website. Read our Advertising Disclosure.

When starting a trip, whether it’s for work, leisure, or exploration, one of the initial choices we confront is selecting the appropriate luggage. In the world of travel equipment, the decision typically revolves around two primary categories: soft-sided luggage and hard-sided luggage. Each type has its own distinct characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages, underscoring the importance of grasping the subtleties prior to making a decision. Soft-sided luggage, prized for its pliability and light weight, is made from materials that allow for added flexibility, making it perfect for travelers seeking to optimize packing capacity. Conversely, hard-sided

Overview of Softside Luggage

Softside luggage, or soft-shell luggage, is generally constructed from sturdy fabrics such as nylon or polyester. These materials provide flexibility, enabling you to fit in additional clothing or last-minute souvenirs.

Benefits of Softside Luggage

  • Lightweight and Flexible: Softside luggage is often lighter than hardshell options, which is beneficial when trying to comply with airline weight limits. The flexible material also allows for some expansion, providing additional space when needed.
  • Ample External Pockets: Softside luggage is well-loved for its exterior pockets, which offer convenient storage for travel essentials like passports, tickets, and reading materials. This makes it a popular choice for frequent travelers.
  • Fits into Tight Spaces: The flexibility of soft luggage makes it easier to fit into cramped areas such as overhead bins or luggage racks. This feature is especially helpful when traveling in situations where space is limited.

Drawbacks of Softside Luggage

  • Susceptibility to Damage: Despite being constructed from durable materials, softside luggage may not offer the same level of protection for delicate items as hardside luggage. Additionally, it is more prone to wear and tear, especially when subjected to rough handling or adverse weather conditions.

Exploring Hardside Luggage: A Comprehensive Look

Hardside luggage, also known as hard-shell luggage, boasts a firm outer shell. It is crafted from a variety of materials, including advanced plastics such as polycarbonate and ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene), as well as stylish aluminum.

Benefits of Hardside Luggage

  • Enhanced Protection: Hardside luggage offers exceptional protection, safeguarding your items from rough handling and various weather elements. This makes it a great option for transporting fragile belongings.
  • Simple Maintenance: Cleaning hardside luggage is effortless. The durable exterior can be easily wiped down, preserving the new appearance of your luggage for an extended period.
  • Secure Features: Hardside luggage frequently includes built-in TSA-approved locks, enhancing the security of your possessions.

Disadvantages of Hardside Luggage

  • Susceptibility to Visual Damage: While hardside luggage is effective at safeguarding your belongings, it is more susceptible to visible scratches and scuffs. This can impact the overall appearance of your suitcase over time.
  • Limited Packing Versatility: Hardside suitcases typically open like a book, dividing the storage space into two sections. Although this layout facilitates organization, it may present difficulties when packing large items.
  • Absence of Exterior Pockets: The inflexible structure of hardside luggage does not allow for exterior pockets. Consequently, once your items are packed, accessing anything would necessitate opening the entire suitcase.

Exploring Further: Considerations for Choosing Between Softside and Hardside Suitcases

Having examined the fundamental advantages and disadvantages of softside and hardside luggage, let’s now investigate specific factors that may impact your choice.


The type of material used in your luggage is vital in determining its strength, weight, and ability to withstand impacts. Softside luggage is frequently constructed from lightweight but durable materials such as nylon or polyester, providing a level of flexibility and making it a popular option for those who tend to pack heavily.

On the other hand, hardside luggage is usually crafted from rigid materials like polycarbonate, ABS, polypropylene, or aluminum, which offer strong protection for your items but also contribute to the overall weight of the luggage.

Design and Organization

The design and organization of luggage can greatly impact how you pack. Softside luggage typically has a single large compartment with a flat lid, making it easier to pack and providing flexibility to fit more items. In addition, softside luggage often has external pockets for convenient access to essentials.

In contrast, hardside luggage usually has a clamshell design, dividing the storage space into two halves. This design helps with organization but can make it difficult to pack larger or irregularly shaped items. Furthermore, hardside luggage generally does not have external pockets, which limits quick access to items once packed.


The importance of the weight of your luggage cannot be overstated, especially when considering strict airline weight limits. Softside luggage is frequently favored by frequent travelers due to its lighter weight compared to hardside luggage. Nonetheless, certain hardside materials such as polypropylene can also provide lightweight alternatives.


Softside luggage excels in terms of capacity. Its flexible material provides additional packing space, and numerous softside suitcases offer expandable zippers to increase capacity. In contrast, hardside suitcases often do not have expandable features, and the inflexible material does not accommodate overpacking.

In the Ring: Comparing Hardside and Softside Luggage for Different Travel Situations

Various travel situations require specific types of luggage. Let’s examine how hardside and softside luggage perform in different travel scenarios.

For Business Travel

Frequent business travelers often favor softside luggage for their carry-ons. These bags are lightweight, feature convenient external pockets for easy access to essentials, and can easily fit into compact overhead compartments. The flexibility of the material also provides extra packing space, making it ideal for accommodating last-minute additions.

For International Travel

When journeying abroad, the decision between hardside and softside luggage may hinge on the nature of your travel. If you’re headed to a location with unpredictable weather, a hardside suitcase can offer superior protection against the elements. Conversely, if your itinerary includes numerous flights or transfers, a softside suitcase may provide greater flexibility due to its lighter weight and ability to adapt to different spaces.

For Adventure or Outdoor Travel

When journeying abroad, the decision between hardside and softside luggage may hinge on the nature of your trip. If you’re headed to a location with capricious weather, a hardside suitcase can offer superior protection against the elements. On the other hand, if your travels entail numerous flights or transfers, a softside suitcase can provide greater versatility thanks to its lighter weight and ability to fit into different spaces.

For Family Travel

Softside luggage is an excellent choice for family travel as it provides the versatility and flexibility required to pack for multiple individuals. Additionally, the presence of external pockets can be quite useful for storing snacks, toys, or other necessary items for the children.

The Ultimate Combination: Highest-Rated Hardside and Softside Luggage Choices

After carefully examining the advantages and disadvantages of hardside and softside luggage, we will now explore some top choices in both categories.

Best Hardside Luggage

Samsonite Winfield 2 Hardside

The Samsonite Winfield 2 Hardside is well-regarded for its sturdiness and is a favored option for many travelers. With its strong polycarbonate shell providing great protection, ample interior space, and convenient compression straps, it simplifies the packing process.

Samsonite Freeform Carry-on Spinner

The Samsonite Freeform Carry-on Spinner is both lightweight and sturdy, making it a perfect option for individuals who prefer to travel with minimal luggage. It provides generous packing space and is equipped with smooth-rolling spinner wheels for effortless maneuvering.

Calpak Hue Mini Carry-on Luggage

Compact and stylish, the Calpak Hue Mini Carry-on Luggage is perfect for short trips. Its hardshell exterior ensures your belongings are well-protected, while its interior pockets aid organization.

View Price

Best Softside Luggage

Travelpro Platinum Elite Softside Spinner

The Travelpro Platinum Elite Softside Spinner is renowned for its large carrying capacity and integrated compression straps, making it a great choice for extended journeys. Its sturdy material and effortless maneuverability enhance its attractiveness.
View Price

Travelpro Maxlite 5 Carry-on Spinner

One of the lightest carry-on bags in the industry, the Travelpro Maxlite 5 Carry-on Spinner is a favorite among frequent flyers. Its flexible material, spacious interior, and external pockets make packing and accessing essentials effortless.

View Price

Final Thought: Navigating Your Luggage Choice

Deciding whether to opt for softside or hardside luggage depends on evaluating your travel patterns, individual tastes, and the nature of your upcoming trip. If you frequently find yourself on the move, navigating through tight spaces, and requiring fast access to belongings, a softside bag, with its pliable materials and exterior pockets, may be the most suitable choice. Conversely, travelers who prioritize protection against the stresses of travel, particularly for fragile items, and prefer easy maintenance, might lean towards hard-shell suitcases, despite their absence of external pockets and tendency to show wear over time.
Both kinds of luggage have progressed, with manufacturers conducting thorough abrasion and drop tests, and creating products that aim to provide a balance of strengths – such as hard-shell luggage with adaptable compartments or durable soft-side luggage. The decision also extends beyond just soft and hard shells, encompassing factors like size (carry-on vs. checked), internal organization, and special features such as packing cubes or water-resistant materials.
Ultimately, the decision is very individualized and dependent on the specific circumstances. Someone who travels frequently for business may prefer a softshell carry-on for short trips, while a family going on an international vacation might choose a luggage set that offers both hard and soft options. It’s important to consider that the best carry-on or checked bag should not only meet the airline’s requirements but also fit your travel preferences, making your journey more seamless and enjoyable. When deciding between hard and soft luggage, it’s important to consider not only the material but also how it will impact your travel experience. There’s no right or wrong answer, just the best choice for your upcoming adventure.